Banned Book


What Is A Book Ban?

As the 1st of October brings Banned Books Week, starting with what exactly a modern book ban to set the stage would be helpful!

Book banning is a form of censorship. The Encyclopedia Britannica defines it as,

“the practice of prohibiting or restricting the reading of certain books by the general public or by members of a local community or religious group. Books can be banned by means of their removal from publicly accessible locations (e.g, libraries), by their destruction (including the burning of printed books), or by making their authorship or distribution a punishable act.”

The current book bans occurring specifically in the United States come due to a want to censor what people read. Censoring is “the suppression of words, images, or ideas that are “offensive” and usually “happens whenever some people succeed in imposing their personal political or moral values on others.”

School book bans are very similar. PEN America defines those as,

“any action taken against a book based on its content and as a result of parent or community challenges, administrative decisions, or in response to direct or threatened action by lawmakers or other governmental officials, that leads to a previously accessible book being either completely removed from availability to students, or where access to a book is restricted or diminished.”

Opponents of book bans, like this blog and many other incredible institutions out there like PEN America and United Against Book Bans, argue that the ability to access these books is protected under our First Amendment right.

It should also be highlighted that book bans are NOT the same thing as determining if a book is age appropriate. Book bans remove access to everyone in a determined group/community. Educators choosing to not recommend a book, or read a book, due to some themes for a class due to the age of the class is not a book ban, as those students can still choose to access the book.

Here at MyLibraryCardWoreOut, I fully believe in reading books that are age appropriate. A young teen should not be reading a smut book at all. Parents can make those specific choices for their child due to their individual and personal maturity. The reason for this is while the parent may not want a child to read something, the child can still access the book if they so choose. This is why clearly explaining why you ban a book is important, and I’ll delve into this more later in the week!

But a blanket book ban removing access to books is not acceptable. What is offensive to one person and one family is not offensive to another and removing someone’s ability to access books is seen as an infringement on our First Amendment right.


Banned Books Week 2023: 1-7 October

With a new month rapidly approaching, it means Banned Books Week is right around the corner! With all the book banning going on right now, this year it seems to be bigger than ever.

So many libraries and book stores are having events, pushing out information and encouraging people to speak out. I’ll be posting things as I find them, and head over to my Instagram to see some banned books posts! Also if you’re just looking to keep on top of things, check out @stopbookbans where I really focus on this concern.

But PENAmerica is really active this year and has lots of fantastic information!

They do great research of the general pressure of banning books with really great reports.

And they will be having a day of action of October 7th, so be sure to check it out!

Also, like always, you can go check out some Banned Books to buy here to keep knowledgeable! Knowledge is power!


How To Fight Book Bans

With the book bans, book censoring and book restricting going on right now, you may be asking how you are able to help. I wanted to share a great post written by the Authors Guild over on United Against Book Bans.

A post was written titled “Fighting For The Freedom To Read And The Freedom To Write” with some small things that you can do. They include speaking out, joining a book club that reads banned books and report book banning.

Also, the Authors Guild has an amazing tool kit to fight banned books!

While these are all small steps, it everyone does their part as they are able to it will make a difference!

 


Florida Schools Banning Shakespeare ‘Raunchiness’

Schools in Florida, the state where book access is rapidly declining, are removing Romeo and Juliet from schools because of the ‘raunchiness’. Schools will only be using specific excerpts from the book in class school.

Due to Florida Parental Rights in Education Act, also known as the ‘Don’t Say Gay” bill, certain topics cannot be taught in school.

Students can choose to read these books on their own, however, I don’t know many high school students who willingly want to read Shakespeare.

According Joseph Cool, a reading teacher at one of the schools, “There’s some raunchiness in Shakespeare because that’s what sold tickets during that time.

To say this is an embarrassment, the removal and censoring of one of the most classic and well known pieces of literature is beyond sad.

For students, you may be asking where you can access Romeo & Juliet for free online because maybe you’re curious! Don’t worry, I got you!

You can find a version of the full text here, here, and No Fear Shakespeare – Romeo and Juliet text here! You can also get your own copy from Amazon here.

If you’re from Florida and dislike all this book banning, find your representative here, reach out and tell them to stop limiting access to books!


Book Banning & Book Stores: Texas Edition

There are new concerns just beginning to be realized connected to book banning. On top of the wrongness of book banning (you can read some of my posts about it here), bookstores are now worried how this will impact them.

In a new article, Texas booksellers have expressed their concern with the new requirements to analyze and rate books for “sexually explicit” content.

Additionally, with some of these new restrictions, certain books may not be able to be sold any longer which puts bookstores in a predicament. They may begin to lose large amounts of money and many booksellers and publishers in the state say the law is “anti-business.”

According to Valerie Koehler, the owner of the small bookshop Blue Willow Bookshop,

The cost would be formidable. It could possibly put us out of business.

What happens if bookstores don’t do this? Or do it wrong?

According to the article, they will essentially get the death penalty. This means that schools will no longer be able to buy from them. This means that the entire responsibility for reviewing every book – them and making sure the rating is accurate is on all the vendors.

Not only is this a behemoth of an effort, but it may be impossible for certain companies to do. This may be because they do not have the appropriate records and manpower to be able to review the books. Additionally, what exactly does “sexually explicit” mean? That can be quite a

subjective thing depending on the person. 

Small book stores will be massively impacted by this and may not be able to meet the demands which will further hurt small businesses.

In a world where companies like Amazon are already taking over, and most likely will be able to comply with these laws, further restrictions like this do more damage.

If you live in Texas, find your representatives and reach out! Tell them to stop this nonsense! Parents have every right to not allow their own child to read a book, but should not be able to stop a whole district/state from reading certain books.